ZDR Column Behavior in Real and Simulated X-band Radar Observations of Potentially Tornadic Storms

Abstract

The primary objective of this research is to characterize distinct differential reflectivity (ZDR) column

behavior with respect to height, intensity, and aerial coverage prior to tornadogenesis (failure) in X-band

radar observations of supercells. ZDR observations of three supercells observed at high spatiotemporal

resolution with X-band polarimetric radar, two tornadic and one nontornadic, are examined. Similar ZDR

column behavior is found in all three, despite divergent outcomes with respect to tornadogenesis. Simulated

ZDR columns are also generated from a 30-member ensemble of simulated supercells. These simulated ZDR

columns are characterized by height, intensity, and areal coverage just above the 0 °C level. Simulated ZDR

column area and height both increase and ZDR intensity inside the column was higher, on average, in the 5

minutes prior to tornadogenesis, whereas there was no appreciable change in these metrics for tornadogenesis

failure. This result stands in contrast to results from our observational analysis, where there were no

consistent, distinguishable changes in ZDR column metrics prior to tornadogenesis versus failure. This

research pinpoints ZDR column metrics that can be the focus of future study, both through field observations

and numerical simulations.